A scribe walks up to Jesus and asks, “What is the first commandment?”
“The Lord is our God, The Lord alone. You shall love the Lord with all your heart, with all your soul, with all your might. The second is like it, you shall love your neighbor as yourself.” (“Matthew 22:39, John 15:17 NKJV)
And, as one rabbi taught, “Everything else is conversation.”
Jesus places the Ten Commandments into one inseparable relationship with his answer. Every image we have of the Ten commandments depicts two tables. On one table is how we are to live our life before God and the other is how we live together as a community. Yet, the two tables are inseparable. One cannot love God without loving one’s neighbor and one cannot love one’s neighbor without loving God. Choosing to emphasize one at the expense of the other is contrary to what God intends the people of God to do.
Yet too often we do just that. Indeed, many Christians create displays of the ten commandments like the one Roy Moore did when he was running for public office in Alabama. He created a display that weighs 5,280 pounds or about five hundred pounds per commandment, so when he brings this monument to public appearances it needs to be loaded on the back of a flatbed truck. Joshua Green, writing in the Atlantic Monthly a few years ago, notes that whenever the truck returns to Alabama, “a 57-foot yellow I-beam crane that spans the ceiling of the Clark Memorials warehouse drops down to retrieve the Rock from its chariot, and even this one — a five-ton crane/ — buckles visibly under the weight.”
“I know,” as Professor Tom Long writes, “that Jesus once scolded the Pharisees for neglecting the weightier matters of the law, but somehow this I-beam-bending version of the Decalogue seems way out of proportion.”
But it makes the perfect point about the way the Ten Commandments have become a heavy burden in our contemporary culture. Every conversation I hear about them has some commentator wagging a finger at another person saying, “thou shalt not!” as if the commandments were created by God to be a moral imperative, a checklist for deciding whether someone is getting into heaven or not, rather than being the structure forming and shaping a community of health and well-being. Of course, for other folks, the commandments are a legalistic framework used to place heavy yokes publicly on the necks of rebellious children or a society out of control. I mean listen to the words of Luther’s Small Catechism, “God threatens to punish everyone who breaks these commandments. We should be afraid of His anger because of this and not violate such commandments.” (“The Ten Commandments – Bible Hub”)
I suppose all these understandings of the Decalogue makes a two-and-a-half-ton rock sitting on the bed of a truck seem to be about a perfect symbol for what the Ten Commandments might be. Especially, since we seem to have forgotten that the Babylonians’ gods were heavy idols that had to be trucked around, “These things you carry,” Isaiah chided the Israelites, “are loaded as burdens on weary animals” (Isa. 46:1).
The problem is that all the ways we use the Ten Commandments or the ten words as they are referred to in Hebrew scripture fails to recognize they are about liberation and are God’s rule of love. They are given as an expression of God’s liberating the people from slavery out of the love God has for people. Indeed, the reading begins with, “I am the Lord your God, who brought you out of the house of slavery.” God liberates the Hebrews from slavery, then freely provides them all they need for life, including how to be free and loving as a community of health, well-being, mutuality, loving-kindness, and wholeness. Indeed, as Walter Brueggemann, Old Testament scholar, points out, “these ten commands are to be the bedrock of God’s intention for Israel, from which all other commands in Israel is understood to be derivative. “
Also, these commands are created to establish a social rule contrasted with that of pharaoh, so that the people do not attempt to replicate the governance of pharaoh with its coercion, brutality, dehumanization of other peoples, and exploitation of other peoples within the community. Thus, this community of God’s people are to practice God’s justice instead of pharaoh’s injustice and to establish neighborly well-being instead of coercion, fear, and exploitation.
You see, God does not intend to re-enslave people with these commands, but to set them free as if to say, “you are free not to need any other gods or even to make 5,280-pound images of God to truck around. You are free to rest on the seventh day because you, your animals, your servants, your land all need rest from productivity, so you can all be healthy and enjoy a long life. You are no longer at the mercy of an oppressor working you to death and you are not something to be used up or consumed until there is nothing left of you. You, the powerless, are free from the rapacious capacity of the strong because I, the Lord, have set limits to the acquisitive capacity of members of the community. You are free from some members who want to take what another member of the community needs for life.
You are free from the tyranny of lifeless idols made of stones or wood; free from solving every problem with violence and you can instead look for ways to solve problems with other people and tribes, so everyone wins and gets what they need for life because there is abundance for all. You are free to find ways to sustain life for yourselves, for neighbors and for all creation. You are free from having to covet what your neighbor has because you both have everything you need for life and, by the way, you are free from having to compare yourself with your neighbor or find your self-worth based upon what you or your neighbor owns or can do because you are loved just as you are and you are free to celebrate other people’s gifts because you have valuable gifts, too.
Or as another theologian has written “You want to make an idol of this God, an image of bird, snake, tree, pole, money, fame, or pleasure? This God will have none of that because this is the God who brought you out of slavery. You want to trivialize the name of this God by slapping God’s name onto any fool thing you already want to do, thereby baptizing your idiocy with a divine seal of approval, thereby enslaving oneself in the bondage of self-satisfied power. God will have none of that either, for that is also a kind of slavery from which you need to be free.”
“God says, I want you free, because I am in the freedom business. All the ways you can imagine falling back into slavery and death, God is there to call you out to freedom and life, because that is who God is. God is life and freedom. It is God who has brought us out of the house of slavery and God can surely do so again, bringing us the lasting freedom of grace.
Not only that, but God’s good news of life should be like music with the Ten Commandments the dance steps that set us moving together, as Tom Long has suggested. They are supposed to be our wings, so we might soar on the wind of the Holy Spirit. This is one of the reasons Luther, also, suggested to change the language of the commandments from “thou shalt not” to more positive language that evokes the freedom God’s love intends for us to enjoy, so instead of “thou shalt not bear false witness against your neighbor” perhaps ‘find joy in telling the truth, being honest and upholding the goodness and good name of your neighbor as if pronouncing a blessing upon your neighbor.”
Also, if we want to pass this good news of freedom and life to our children, then we are going to have to be creative; more creative than hanging the Ten Commandments on a wall, memorizing them in order or hauling them around on a flatbed truck. I suggest we create stories because as Robert Wuthnow writes, “”Stories do more than keep memories alive. Sometimes these stories become so implanted in our minds that they act back upon us, directly and powerfully.”
Wuthnow tells the story of Jack Casey, a volunteer firefighter and ambulance attendant who, as a child, had to have some of his teeth extracted under general anesthesia. Jack was terrified, but a nurse standing nearby said to him, “Don’t worry, I’ll be here right beside you no matter what happens.” When he woke up from the surgery, she had kept her word, and she was still standing beside him.
This experience of being cared for by the nurse stayed with him, and 20 years later his ambulance crew was called to the scene of an accident. The driver was pinned upside down in his pickup truck, and Jack crawled inside to try to get him out of the wreckage. Gasoline was dripping onto both Jack and the driver, and there was a danger of fire because power tools were being used to free the driver, the whole time, the driver was crying out about how scared of dying he was, and Jack kept saying to him, recalling what the nurse had said so many years before, “Look, don’t worry, I’m right here with you, I’m not going anywhere.” Later, after the truck driver had been safely rescued, he was incredulous. “You were an idiot “he said to Jack. “You know that thing could have exploded, and we’d have both been burned up.” In reply, Jack simply said he felt he just could not leave him.
This is how the commandments are supposed to work, as Tom Long says it, “We have the experience of being cared for, the experience of being set free and loved, preserved in a story. Then, comes the life shaped ethically around that story. A nurse saying, “I’ll be right here beside you” becomes the action of a man risking his life for a stranger because he knows in his bones that he just cannot leave him.”
“I am the Lord your God, who brought you . . . out of the house of slavery” prompts us to live lives shaped by the love and freedom created by God,” asserts Tom Long.
And I got to believe living God’s joyous freedom and love held within the Ten Commandments is much better than carrying around tons of dreary duty, just hoping the wheels do not come off the flatbed truck of our lives.